tl;dr: Do you think that creating an up-to-date Shield List that has more features and does not rely on a single person is a good idea
would you maybe even want to help?
Is there a need to add the exact ICSP pins? Most shields don't even have the headers, do they only have them if they use them?
I welcome suggestions for any other free solution that is owned by a major organization (to not rely on donations or a single person's will) and allows collaboration, easy export of the entire project and is free of ads, unwanted cookies and trackers. Wikis might be easier to edit, but their are harder to host and browse/search/filter (I do know DPL, but I also know it's limitations).