I have done some of that chromagenic (although I didn't know it's name). I thought it looked about the same as digital shots that I got printed at a good online store with a specialized b&w printer. I think my eyes are used to a certain film/paper combination and they just like that look. That said they don't like it enough to make me set down my digital most of the time because to me digital is just so convenient. Maybe someday when I'm older and better at photography I'll use film more often again.