Adafruit says 5-10k in light and 200k in dark.
I have a few with different resistance, but they are below 1k in full (sun)light and above 1M in full darkness.
Do you mean "full dark" really as "full dark" ? Putting your finger on it is not enough.
Suppose it is 200k and the resistor is 10k.
V = 10k / (10k+200k) * 5V = 0.238V = 48.
It should be 48 and not 800.
Could you make a photo ?
Show us your sketch. Are you sure you have "A1" in the sketch (and not A0) ?
To get more range out of my LDR I don't use a single resistor of 10k. I use two output pins, one with 1k to the LDR and one with 100k to the LDR. The other pin of the LDR to GND. Then I power it with the 1k and I power it with the 100k and I average both results.
Measure the resistance of the sensor with a DMM in the light conditions you want to use it in.
e.g. if you want to use it as a dusk/dawn sensor, measure it at that light.
Then pick a fixed resistor of about that value.
You might find that 100k works better in dim light situations, while 10k is better for bright light detection.
Leo..