Go Down

Topic: Makerbeam or Openbeam (Read 96 times) previous topic - next topic

Hi Gents.

Simple question: Should i buy Makerbeam or Openbeam?

I know the question will come: what purpose is it for? The purpose it is designed for: Rapid prototyping.
Robotics mainly. Attaching a few Servos. Build a chassis for a Hexapod, maybe build a small 'car-like' robot with 2-4 wheels. That's not the point here.

Question is: Which one is better quality? Which one has more addons (Bearings /Servo-Brackets etc).

In my country the starter sets are expensive. MakerBeam like 140 Bucks, OpenBeam is even 170.-

I want to be sure to buy the right one.

Thanks for your assistance.

robtillaart

It is indeed quite expensive, I sometimes wonder if it would be cheaper to 3D print beams...

Rob Tillaart

Nederlandse sectie - http://arduino.cc/forum/index.php/board,77.0.html -
(Please do not PM for private consultancy)

cr0sh

Extruded t-slot is what you are trying to buy. Personally, these "maker" t-slot profiles, while interesting, always turn out to be relatively expensive, though they do have certain qualities that make them nice. They also tend to fall into a category of where you are always wondering where to buy the stuff, because it seems vendors are always running out, or dropping the product, etc. I tend to wonder how long they will last in the market.

If you can live with slightly larger stuff - then you might look into one of the "standard" t-slot profile systems, like 80/20, Fastenal, Futura, etc.

These guys (especially 80/20) are industry standards, but their smallest profiles tend to be slightly larger than the "maker profiles" you see out there. This can be a plus, though, as it will lend rigidity to your projects. Furthermore, since many of these have been on the market for many years (or decades), you can find a ton of 3rd party stuff as well for many of them. Also, ordinary hardware will (in general) work ok with many of them.

Another option, that might be cheaper - if you can live with the heavier weight - is steel perforated extrusions (Unistrut is a well known brand). Many times, you can pick the stuff up at most hardware stores. Typically, you can easily buy it from metal suppliers locally as well. That, and some nice bolts, plus a hacksaw or other cutter - then using gridbeam construction - you can make some really nice things, that will be really solid. It will be pretty heavy stuff - but then again, you can easily attach other things to it, as well as easily weld to it (without needing a TIG welder, or a MIG with a spool-gun).
I will not respond to Arduino help PM's from random forum users; if you have such a question, start a new topic thread.

Tower

Hi johnnygueggu,

I faced the same question some months ago and bought both starter kits for comparison. I think both are worth the money, you can assemble prototypes very fast. Actually you can also combine both kits in the same prototype as both use the same screw diameter.

Makerbeam
The beams are smaller, best for weight optimized designs. Special screws

Openbeam
The beams are larger, more rigid and come with more weight. Standardized screws

Hope that helps

Go Up