I want a mail for that topic without having to check the "Notify of replies:x Check this if you wish to be notified of replies to this topic"-Thingy
OK, I get it now.
I'd have to say that I wouldn't like a default of "notify on". If we're gonna do an email list, do an email list, but the email messages "go check the forum" seem kinda pointless to me for the most part - sure, if I need help, I want to know the answer ASAP

, but in general it's a pain.
It would be nice if the software handled that as a user-definable preference, though.
I guess I'm just an old phart, but I vastly prefer an email list over a forum. The Arduino is the first forum I've bothered with on a serious basis - it's the first time the information received was worth the trouble.
-j