I agree.. With a guitar you shouldn't need an op-amp.
Just for future reference -
It seemed strange to me that I would need 2x9v batteries.
It's usually easier (and often better) to run an op-amp from positive and negative voltages. The cheapest & easiest way to do that is with 2 batteries.
Now in this tutorial it says that you need 2 9-volt batteries in series (the middle to ground) to generate the positive and negative 9 volts for an op amp...
...and negative 9 volts for an op amp.
...and +/- 4.5 volt for an op amp.
That's confusing and I'm not sure what voltages you really need. I assume You are not using +/-4.5V supplies, but a 9V supply and a virtual ground at 4.5V.
If you need +9V and -9V, that's two batteries (not 3). The Arduino has a voltage regulator so it can run from the same 9V battery as the +9V power for the op-amp.
Now the same author have made a tutorial for an audio input for the arduino (offsetting the signal so there is no negative signal going into the arduino)
You can do similar things with an op-amp to run it from a single supply.
[
My problem is I really don't want to use 3 of my power-suppy outtakes to power a single pedal.
If you've got something like
this, the outputs probably have common grounds so you can't get -9V or connect the outputs in series.