Go Down

Topic: 20 years of coding and I can't find this bug. Can you? (Read 1 time) previous topic - next topic


Hi all.

I built the Makelangelo, a robot that draws murals.  The firmware is for a RUMBA board, which is arduino compatible - think a Mega 2560 and a RAMPS shield on a single PCB.  The firmware is heavily based on Marlin 3D printer firmware.  It supports several different kinematic systems like arms, corexy, polargraphs, etc.  The polargraph is the subject today.


in release version 7.15.3 people noticed something strange - when the Makelangelo v5 is told to go home (send G28 at 57600 baud with newline) the robot (polargraph.ino, robot_findHome()) will touch both limit switches (expected) drive back to home position (fine) and then it should print "Done".  Only it gets to "Do-" and reboots.

The same does not happen in 7.15.0.  I took a copy of 7.15.0 and started adding features in one at a time to see if I could isolate the feature that caused the reboot.  As best I can tell,

       MENU_ACTION("Find home", LCD_find_home);

in lcd.ino line ~160 is the culprit.  Which is 2#$*(! odd, because that code is not being called at the time the error occurs.  The method LCD_find_home() calls on robot_findHome() but the call stack does not include LCD_find_home().  Commenting out the lines above and recompiling makes the bug go away.

My best guess is that there is a much older off by one error somewhere, and compiling the code in juuuust the right way causes that off by one to poke the wrong bit of ram and BOOM reboot.

Having torn out what's left of my hair looking for it, I'm at a loss.  I need fresh eyes to look over my shoulder and say "put the red seven on the black eight", to spot the thing that's right in front of me that I'm missing.

Can you see it?  Would you please tell me?  I'm out of ideas.

Edit: a word.
Edit 2: link was to software when it should have been to firmware. Oops.
Dance as if no one is watching; post as if it is going to be read aloud as evidence in court.


This code works
Code: [Select]
#define MAGIC 5

void setup()

#if MAGIC == 5

void loop()

Could it be that   MACHINE_HARDWARE_VERSION   was not defined at all?
Rob Tillaart

Nederlandse sectie - http://arduino.cc/forum/index.php/board,77.0.html -
(Please do not PM for private consultancy)


Just came across this and was intrigued...

In robot_polargraph.h
Code: [Select]
#define NUM_MOTORS           (2)

In robot_polargraph.ino
Code: [Select]

void robot_findHome() {
long count[NUM_MOTORS];
  count[0] = calibrateLeft/THREAD_PER_STEP;
  count[1] = calibrateRight/THREAD_PER_STEP;
  count[2] = axies[2].pos;                      <-----------Oops !!!



int pushButton = 10;
int buttonState = 0;
int frequency =0;
int balance =6319;
ArduinoFreqMetr v 1.0
#include <FreqMeasure.h>

void setup() {
  pinMode(pushButton, INPUT);
   pinMode(2, OUTPUT); //red
   pinMode(3, OUTPUT); // blue
   pinMode(4, OUTPUT); // green
   pinMode(7, OUTPUT); // buzer

double sum=0;
int count=0;

void loop() {
  if (FreqMeasure.available()) {
    // average several reading together
    sum = sum + FreqMeasure.read();
    count = count + 1;
    if (count > 30) {
      frequency = FreqMeasure.countToFrequency(sum / count);
      sum = 0;
      count = 0;
buttonState = digitalRead(pushButton);
if (buttonState == HIGH) {

if (frequency==balance) {
digitalWrite(3, HIGH);
digitalWrite(7, LOW);
} else {
digitalWrite(3, LOW);
digitalWrite(7, HIGH);


if (frequency>balance) {
digitalWrite(4, HIGH);
} else {
digitalWrite(4, LOW);

if (frequency<balance) {
digitalWrite(2, HIGH);
} else {
digitalWrite(2, LOW);


Code: [Select]
if (frequency>balance) {
digitalWrite(4, HIGH);
} else {
digitalWrite(4, LOW);

Why the superfluous semicolon after the else blocks?
|| | ||| | || | ||  ~Woodstock

Please do not PM with technical questions or comments.  Keep Arduino stuff out on the boards where it belongs.

Go Up