Hello,
I have been getting input from my raspberry pi's GPIO pins on my Arduino, and I'm not sure if this started before or after I started doing this but now if I plug a jumper wire into a pin on my Arduino and read from it it always returns high, even if the jumper wire isn't connected to something on the other side.
An open input pin without a pull-up or pull-down resistor will read randomly HIGH or LOW. In your case it seems to be HIGH. Connect a pull-down resistor (1K Ohm) between the pin and Ground if you want the open pin to read LOW.