I found the following suggested fix, just in case someone sees this post and has a similar problem. I think it would work for me, but can't say for sure because I think my problem is a blown Arduino board.
http://forum.arduino.cc/index.php?topic=198539.0
I remember that I cross wired the control and power leads on my servo. After talking to my buddy who's a EE, he said it's likely it's blown. Also I connected the Arduino to a windows machine and another Mac. All three computers yield the same results, namely bubkis. So I just ordered a new Arduino. Hopefully it will work! 