Yes, it's possible, when I am using I2C the other analogs also works great. But like in other post i recommend to use ADS1115 or ADS1118, you get more stable values from SHARPs. ADS1115 also works in I2C, so if your arduino can not deal with analogs and I2C in the same time, that solve your problem 
because you will get values form SHARPS in I2C protocol.