I fried my (most likely be counterfeit) Mega 2560 ;_;

Most likely your voltage regulator was killed.

ince I pulled the plug out almost instantly

Think: electrons are very very fast ...

Do you remember the spot where the smoke had its chimney?

That's most likely the voltage regulator, but depending on the cause of the failure it could be something else, so before guessing around:
Can you post a sharp picture of the suspect location?