LEDs Charlieplexing vs multiplexing over long distance

Application:
automatic selector of wine bottle from wine cellar: I would have a 132 bottle wine rack (1.2x1.8 m) to which I want to add LEDs (was thinking 5mm, red) below each bottle for rapid selection. I am currently considering a maximum distance of about 3 meters from my arduino mega 2560 R3 to the furthest LED. At most 1 LED would be ON at any given time.

I am reasonably new to all this so I am having a bit of a hard time choosing between charlieplexing my solution or multiplexing the LEDs.

With my understanding of chalieplexing, I would just need 12 digital IO pins and 12 220 Ohm resistors. Only 2 LEDs would be connected to each pair of IO pins, so the driving current would not be a problem. The downside is that I would have a lot of cables (264) to connect to the breadboard. I am also a bit unsure on the diameter sizing of the cable to employ.

Using a multiplexing approach instead, I would require 11+12 = 23 digital IO pins: 12 pins and 12 220 Ohm resistances for the anode lines, and 11 pins for the cathode lines. The idea was to use a single wire (AWG22) for each pin, to which the LEDs are attached by using a T-connector. I am not sure if I would need any more components for this solution (transistors?).

Could you suggest which solution would be best? (Also taking into account the coding difficulty in either case)

I'm not an expert on either of those, but the wiring seems tedious to me. Have you considered using shift registers?

1 Like

I think you should consider addressable wires.
That would save you a lot of wiring. There is 'christmas tree lighting' like addressable leds...
Each cable to a breadboard is a chance for a bad connection. With 264 wires you can be almost sure to have one bad contact..

2 Likes

Interesting…
Can you explain addressable wires further ?

Addressable LEDS..

Individually Addressable LEDs

have fun.. ~q

1 Like

Sorry for confusion, I meant addressable LEDs.

1 Like

:+1::heart::ok_hand::hugs::joy:

make them bottles dance..

Nano Wine Rack..

needs some tlc, too sleepy.. :slight_smile:

have fun.. ~q

This topic was automatically closed 180 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.