The xtal caps are 22 pF +- 5%, so they should be fine. I wanted to verify for my sanity, but I think my handheld multimeter has too much capacitance on the leads because it reads closer to 200 pF when I read them (I would be worried if the capacitors weren't clearly labelled 22J, which should be 22 pF).
I'll start with another fresh board and see where this goes. Any suggestions on where/how to hunt down a possible short?