SDA and SCL not analog pins

OK - The point is to show YOUR wiring, not adafruits! How can we be sure you know what you are talking about if all you say is "And again, the Adafruit diagram should suffice for a schematic".

As others will testify, linking to an external schematic, then showing your own wiring has resolved errors on many occasions.

If you don't post YOUR WIRING as an image, I'm out!