Thanks for the advice everyone.
I think I burnt out servo 2. Like I mentioned it only goes from 0 to 180. Nowhere in between.
I know it is the servo because I can disconnect from one and plug right into 2 and get different behavior. No changing of the code or anything. I feel if they are the same servo, which the are, they should both stall out or not stall out. That’s what makes me think I broke 2.
What advice would you recommend for powering the servos?