Unneeded dependency in SD.h

The file "SD.h" links to SdFatUtils, in line 21:
#include "utility/SdFatUtil.h"

This is - as far as I see - not required and only makes troubles if you want to avoid having the Serial declared for your project.
The line could simply be commented out.

(btw: The page SD - Arduino Reference should have a link to this forum, but the link there is wrong / dead)


Can you provide some more details? Can't remember having had problems (but I don't use the library often enough to remember).

Issue reported on github: SD reference, forum link equals OOPS when following · Issue #11574 · arduino/Arduino · GitHub

In development version I add serial writes for debugging purposes. As this code should not be active in the deployed version, it's deactivated usign define-blocks.
To find potentially unwanted code accessing the serial I currently use this code:

// #define DEBUG
#ifndef DEBUG
  // Avoid that debug code remains in release version
  #define Serial RaiseErrorIfForgotInCode

This doesn't work if the SD lib is in use.
But for me the most important thing: Why should the SD lib link to a library that is not used anyway?

Probably just redundant code due to an oversight, and clearly nothing to get concerned about.

This topic was automatically closed 120 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.