Hi jrsikken,
Just waking up with my first café, so if I misunderstand, I apologise.
Firstly, without seeing all your code, it appears to me that you may be using the WebDuino library, is this correct?
Secondly, you are issuing a http GET by supplying the data in your URL line, but looking at your code you have on the third line down the following;
if (type == WebServer::POST)
Is this not then wanting to see a http POST structure?
If so, I think the Webduino library is then defaulting to give you the lovely 'Epic Fail'.
If your code is in one file, it might be worth your while to show it all.
Tot ziens,
Paul