Advanced Editor AI Assistant

I was hoping this would be a free addition, but its not , ho hum.

I don't use the Arduino cloud much, only so far for the learning experience, so the free account is fine for that.

Whats the general opinion on this , is it worth subscribing , does it dumb you down ??

I assume you are referring to AI.
It is handy for playing with code snippets, but it can not write applications unless the code already exists in the global cloud.
The problem is that the less experienced tend to use it more and can't recognize bad responses from good ones. Basically, that means it works almost in reverse in terms of a teaching tool.

Hi @hammy. The AI Assistant feature is available even when using the free Arduino Cloud plan.

As far as I know, the difference between the plans in regards to the AI Assistant is only in the limit on the number of interactions. The Free plan gives you an allowance of 30 interactions per month. The number is increased to 1500 for the Maker plan:

https://cloud.arduino.cc/plans#features-table

So you can try it out to see if you find it useful even without signing up for a paid plan. It is true that if you end up using it frequently you will run into the limit imposed by the Free plan, but if you are using it that much then perhaps you will decide that it is worthwhile to pay for the service. I would guess that the 1500 interactions per month granted by the paid Maker plan will be more than enough for most people, and the Maker plan is fairly affordable.

I'm not sure I understand correctly what you mean by this, but although they learned from the code available on the Internet, LLMs don't just copy and paste existing code. They instead generate code. The Arduino AI Assistant absolutely can write you a complete unique sketch.

Since your participation in this topic indicates an interest in the subject matter, I suggest you give it a try. That will allow you to better understand the nature of LLMs. If nothing else, LLMs are at least undeniably impressive from a technical standpoint. Even if we chose not to use them personally (as you pointed out, they are far from perfect tools), we are still going to encounter their products indirectly as there is significant usage of them by the population in general. It seems unlikely that is going to change any time soon.

I think there is some sort of misunderstanding about this. I do not see any way that an AI can 'create' code for real business applications like payroll, accounts payable, accounts receivable, general ledger, operating statements, numerous inventory systems using different criteria for re-order points and so on. In a Fortune 500 company, these processes take dozens of humans several years with gigabytes of communications, which must be translated from the written word to code. It is simply a different process compared to writing a single sketch.

You are moving the goalposts. You only said "it can not write applications" in your previous post. We are talking about the Arduino AI Assistant here, so I interpreted "applications" as referring to a complete Arduino sketch. The AI Assistant can indeed write complete Arduino sketches. It is true that there are limitations regarding how much code content the LLM can produce per response. However, even in that case you can make a separate request for it to add each component of the sketch, and thus build sketches that contain more content than could be produced all at once.

And even expanding the scope of the discussion beyond the specific Arduino AI Assistant feature, LLMs are certainly capable of producing the codebase of full applications of any kind. As with Arduino sketches, I'm sure there will be a limit to how much content a given LLM can produce in one go. However it is likely you wouldn't want to generate an entire large application in one go anyway. Rather you would take a modular approach, regardless of whether it was a human or AI writing the code.

Please understand that I am not advocating for using any AI service to write your applications for you. I am only pushing back against your claim that they are only capable of producing snippets, and applications only through a pure copy/pasting of an existing codebase. That simply isn't true. Are they prone to making mistakes and "hallucinations"? Absolutely, but that is a different subject.

Thanks for the discussion , I’ll look again to see if it’s free - might be my mistake there .