However it says it sorts by relevance. What constitutes relevance?
Searching for several things the #1 item has had 96 views and appears twice. The #2 item has 991 views and appears 16 times on the first page. It is something I abandoned.
The item with 547320 views does not appear at all even though it comes out #1 with DDG.
To my mind this Arduino search is currently not fit for purpose and should not have been rolled out.
As I said earlier, if it can't do better than Google (or DDG) it is a waste of time since there was already a Google search in use on the Forum.
IMHO google just spit out a load of mish mash for Arduino certainly not in any sort of decent order most of the time nor as relevant on other occasions.
ballscrewbob:
IMHO google just spit out a load of mish mash for Arduino certainly not in any sort of decent order most of the time nor as relevant on other occasions.
With several things site:arduino.cc Google also put the Thread several things at a time as #1
The Forum search did not even have it on the first page.
Thanks everyone for the warm welcoming! some quick replies:
I think that it would be helpful if the search was opened in a new tab in the browser rather than leaving the current page, or maybe offer the option by right clicking on the search icon. As it stands, if you want to do a search whilst reading a thread then in order to leave the thread open you need to duplicate the page before doing the search.
Good shout @UKHeliBob. I am referring this to the team. I am also referring the alerts issue too. We work mainly with the search but I am sure there's something we can do
The item with 547320 views does not appear at all even though it comes out #1 with DDG.
@Robin2 you are right as this behaviour is very odd. It should definitely be within the first results. We'll have a look at it to see what's going on. I'll let you know as soon as we figure it out
@Robin2 you are right as this behaviour is very odd. It should definitely be within the first results. We'll have a look at it to see what's going on. I'll let you know as soon as we figure it out
Perhaps it would be a good idea to restore the earlier search system that used Google while the bugs are being removed from the new system?
ballscrewbob:
The option to jump to google is still there Robin.
God forbid I would need to use it.
I confess I don't often need to search for stuff on the Forum by any means but from what I can see the existing Forum Search is completely useless and would be best decommissioned until it is fixed.
I don't share your view that Google is incompetent. I normally use Duck Duck Go to stay out of Google's clutches but Google's search capability is very good IMHO.
If you have some examples where the Arduino Search is better than Google or DDG I would be interested to hear about them. As I said earlier, if the Arduino Search is not better then the whole thing is a waste of time.
Unfortunately not available in all sections of search.
neither is the drop to google option unfortunately.
But just using "testing site:www.arduino.cc" on google brings up the following which clearly indicates awkward date structures and a randomness of selected items.
The "relevance" and date order options have a bad habit of not sticking.
If I "choose newest" first I expect it to STICK and not drop back to "relevance"
In this case I was using the term driver error code 10 and simply added the specifiers to make it driver error "code 10" to refine my results.
Also if I am going to get the last users search terms then they should really be in most sought after order in terms of quantity so if 10 people looked for "broken" then broken would be top of the list of initial offerings and above 3 searches for broke etc.
"broken" vs "broke" is a difficult one. Google and DDG are smart enough to figure out equivalent words and don't slavishly (couldn't resist) restrict the search to the particular word or spelling unless you put it in quotes. Most of the time I find that very useful because I often am not sure of the most appropriate search term.
What people really want is the most useful answer and it might be associated with "broke" rather than "broken", or even with "faulty".
I'm not pretending that an effective search system is simple - it certainly is not.
I have just used the new search to search for uint64_t It is less than helpful to be presented with 2,600 results, most of which have nothing to do with what I was searching for, although they do contain the letter t at the start of a word and it is helpfully highlighted for me so that I don't miss seeing them. This is with the default parameters selected. How could the word the be considered more relevant than the actual text I searched for ?
Is this new search facility being tested by letting (forcing) users to use it ?
I broke that down and neither google or the new search was particularly useful.
"uint" site:www.arduino.cc on google gets 3 results !
"uint" on Arduino gets 1,069 for just the forum.
Not too sure what to deduce from that?
Has Arduino turned off google scrapes ?
Or was that actually all google could find ?
EDIT
I think Arduino has turned off scrapes...
Change "uint" to "uint8" and try both searches to see what I mean. (use the quotes)
I think the answer to your question may be that we are being FORCED to use the new search which IF it is true is unacceptable to me.
Prefer options not limitations.
UPDATE:
It seems the use google option pushes www. which breaks the google search.
Removal of that part fixes it so it is a BUG
"uint16" site:arduino.cc works but arduino sends "uint16" site:www.arduino.cc
To be honest I can't remember. I know what the term means and I suspect that I was interested to see how frequently it was used in the Arduino environment
The results that I got just proved how useless the new forum search mechanism is and that Google search beats it hands down