No I am not running a temperature or otherwise delirious. The site search is extremely basic which makes searching for specific posts, which one has a vague memory of seeing but can give only a few key words, extremely difficult. It does not handle spelling errors, synonyms very well and is generally very narrow in scope. I have much more success using google outside of the site but then it is difficult to constrain its search to results from the forum. Anyway, why should it be necessary to go to an external tool to get the required information. One of the few good things about the inbuilt search is that you can give usernames in the form of @MyName to focus the search and I think that should be retained if possible.
I'm guessing that Discourse has such a feature, or at least something better than we currently have, just waiting to be activated. It is quite good at listing near equivalent posts under "Related Topics" once a thread is opened.
It would be nice to have it built-in to the forum software but as you say, using Google or another search engine does work well but requires you to filter the results manually.
One can use AI agents to accomplish searches like I think you are wanting. Tools like ChatGPT have a "chat" and a "work" mode. In the work mode, one can set up a task list to search a forum in pretty much any specific way you like.
As you say, it would be nice to have that capability built-in.
I'll give an example of a search I did yesterday which does not produce many really useful results if entered into the forum's inbuilt search:
arduino restarts 2 times when a new sketch is loaded
This is a known problem and Google makes a much better job of it.
This is indeed the main point but I agree that the external alternatives are good and getting better and will rely anyway on information scraped from this site.
Open the "advanced search" page. You can do this by clicking the icon at the right hand side of the search field on the header, or going to this URL: Search results for '' - Arduino Forum
Select "Relevance" from the "Sort by" menu on the search page.
Perform the search.
Move the "Related results" switch on the search page to the "on" position.
With the "Related results" switch in the "off" position, you get the traditional keyword match search results. With the switch in the "on" position, you also get results the LLM has determined to be relevant to your search query, even though they don't have a keyword match.
That indeed works and I tried it with the test search phrase in post #4. The additional items which are returned when " by relevance " is selected are marked with a blue star and amongst those were the useful results.
The scope appears to be limited to forum posts so, for example, support.arduino.cc results are not included.
Well that was quick work. Many thanks for that.
I'm glad that the change is producing better results. I'm generally resistant to adding a lot of AI integration to Arduino Forum (and bells and whistles in general, AI or no), but I am satisfied that this feature is fairly unobtrusive from a UX perspective.
That is correct. support.arduino.cc and forum.arduino.cc are actually completely separate websites under the hood. The Discourse features are specific to forum.arduino.cc, and I don't have any involvement in the development and management of the other sites. So the best I can do is offering AI-enhanced searches for the Arduino Forum content specifically.
I'll still use Google search but now less so for searches across this forum. Actually, the classic (pre-AI) Google search engine was also significantly better that the non-AI enhanced forum search which does not even seem to do a simple synonym substitution, say "2 times" for "twice" as in my example from post #4.
I've now used the new search several times since then and it really is a big improvement.
However, I've see that it could be improved further. I wanted to search for a PM on a subject which was only tangentially related to a post I made and could only really give a data range and a few keywords. I did find the post eventually but a date range search as such does not really exist. I've checked on other specimen Discourse sites and it has not been implemented anywhere so I guess this will be a bit more difficult:
Assuming it can't at the moment be implemented, what is the procedure for making suggestions to Discourse ? Do you do it for requests that you consider valid or is it up to the individual users to make such requests direct to Discourse ?
Indeed. That is all I need.
Earliest date -- Latest date and give me everything in between (inclusive).
I can live without the luxury features like "last 24 hours", "last week" etc.
It is true that the search GUI only allows you to set an upper or a lower bound for the date filter. However, you can manually add both a before: and after: filter to the query:
You can submit feature requests on the Discourse Meta forum:
You should first check whether there is an existing a feature request. I see there is one for being able to set both an after and before date filter via the search GUI:
I do try to escalate bug reports and feature requests made here to Discourse. However, I don't always find time to do that. So I definitely should not be treated as a "gatekeeper" of communication to Discourse. As with many software projects, the Discourse developers don't resolve every request (this being an example of that unfortunately). However, they definitely do pay attention to every bug report and feature request, and do resolve a lot of them. This is an open source project, so the community does have the option of submitting proposals for changes to the codebase directly via a pull request (though of course such proposals will only be accepted when they align with Discourse's vision for the project).
OK. Thanks for that. I didn't understand that the search bar, which is automatically populated with filter expressions as these are selected via the GUI, could be manually updated. That indeed solves my problem of specifying a date range.
Since someone else has already made a similar suggestion for a date range functionality I will not pursue the matter since the suggested work around is fine for my occasional use.
I don't think I'll be using many of the other advanced manual search filters that you referred to here
but I was intrigued by this one:
however, a sample check reveals that it identifies posts by an authorized bot of this site, say which performs maintenance tasks like closing expired posts etc., and does not imply a means of identifying spam type bots which inflict this site.
Thanks @pert for enabling the semantic search — I tried it via Advanced Search with Sort by Relevance and Related results on, and it does surface relevant threads that keyword search missed. I agree with @6v6gt that keeping the username filter is important, as that is useful for following answers from people whose posts I trust. Hopefully the new search helps newcomers find existing answers before starting duplicate topics.