pH sensor and Arduino

I used pH sensor circuit sold on Sparkfun to assemble Arduino UNO controlled pH sensor.
I already had BNC connector and pH sensor probe (Vernier Tris Compatible pH sensor probe).

I used this code found on sparkfun
https://www.atlas-scientific.com/_files/code/Arduino_pH_sample_code.pdf

The sensor worked perfectly until I tried to calibrate it for more precise measurement (it is being used to measure pH of water samples)
I followed their calibration instruction. Ever since I tried to calibrate the sensor with pH4.01 buffer solution, everything got messed up.

When I measured the pH of pH 7.01 buffer solution using the pH sensor I made, I got measures around pH 10.32 up and down.
When I measured the pH of pH 4.01 buffer solution, I got the same readings.
When I measured the pH of pH 10.01 buffer solution, I got "check your sensor".

I even reset the circuit by "x" code, but nothing changes when I measured pH4.01, pH7.01, and pH10.01 buffer solutions.

I cannot find any resources online regarding this problem, and I am also new to Arduino.

It would be fantastic if someone can help me out here.

If nothing changes when you put the probe into solutions with different pH values, there is likely a problem with the circuitry. pH sensing electrodes and amplifiers are extremely delicate and sensitive to mistreatment.