Serial Display shows all counts not just the total

Logically, you have unreachable code.

And you are testing things that, at the point of the test, are known.

You also read the pin and... do nothing.

Here I believe is your loop with all that removed:

void loop()
{
  int value = digitalRead(2);

  delay(10);

  Serial.println(KeyDownCounter);

//  digitalRead(KeyDownPin);  // does no one any good

  if (digitalRead(KeyDownPin) == HIGH)
  {
    KeyDownCounter++;
  }
  else // it is LOW!
  {
    if (KeyDownCounter > 2)
    {
      Serial.println("FINAL Stop");
      KeyDownCounter = 0;
    }
    else
    {
    }
  }
}

As @UKHeliBob says, state change detection will serve you well. A good habit in any case is to read switches once, then use that reading for the rest of the loop.

There's a crap-ton of state change detection tutorials. Google is your friend. Read this post and the thread it finds itself on:

and this thread


HTH a7