I'm unable to get a picture of my circuit, but I've had it checked and confirmed. It's identical to the one on the wiki reference page.
It's almost asif the left side (1,2) of the chip works fine, and the right side doesn't (3,4)
I've tried plugging both coils into the arduino = success
One coil into arduino, one coil into 1,2 = success
One coil into arduino, one coil into 3,4 = failure
both coils into 1,2 and 3,4 = failure
could it be possible that one half of the L293d chip works but the other doesn't?