Adding current limiting resistor - push button with pull down resistor configuration

I would like to use push button with the arduino.

I was wandering if I should add 1k current limiting resistor before the GPIO input pin?

schematic attached.

If so, the 10k pull down resistor placed the way it should or I need to place it to the right of the 1k limiting resistor?

Any disadvantage of putting that 1k limiting resistor apart of components count?

I will not be the only person to use that board and I'm afraid someone else will define that pin as output. In that case - wouldn't it be better adding that limiting resistor?

will that circuit will work the same with the raspberry pi GPIO?

Thanks

The 1K is not necessary as the input impedance (resistance) is very high (100M). That said, it will help to protect the input so is not a bad idea.

I would use 10k on the input as this will afford better protection to a wrongly configured or connected pin .

Have a google of “10 ways to destroy an Arduino” , there are some good protection techniques there

Here

Not necessary.

Do you mean like this

Hello
Take a view.

Many thanks to LarryD

Thanks. Why using pull-down resistor is bad?

the current resistor of LED can be placed either at Cathode or at Anode right?

That requires routing a wire carrying Vcc to the switch. There is then a potential of a dead short (unlimited current) from Vcc to ground or another wire. If a switch is wired to ground with the internal or external pullup shorts the current is limited by the pullup resistor.

Hello
That is not bad.
This will limit the cases of errors possible.

No, I meant in series with the gpio pin , and retain the pull up/pull down .

You’ve had other solutions since , my link is still worth a look

even the Arduino site using pull down resistor in the "button" example https://docs.arduino.cc/built-in-examples/digital/Button

I think that is because many new users have a hard time with 5V being off and 0V being on. That is the only good reason that I can think of.

The best way, even if it contradicts the example, is to wire the switch to ground and use the (free) internal pullup resistor. Then the off (open) switch reads 5V and the on (closed) switch reads low.

And the MCU will wrongly assume the button is pressed which may be more dangerous than the "dead short".

All circuits on LarryD's schematic may damage the pin if it is configured as output by mistake. A current limiting resistor as OP suggests is a very good idea to use when the circuit is going to be reprogrammed by people not aware of this.

Which would be extremely implausible and indicative of bad design. :roll_eyes:

How a "good design" knows if the pin is pulled down by a button pressed by the user or by an electrical fault? Many devices work like "do this dangerous thing as long as the button is pressed." I consider a power rails short circuit (which in a good design "only" clears the fuse and make the whole device inoperational) much safer than the intermittent false button press. The device don't have to be directly dangerous to cause very unpleasant results. For example imagine a faulty thermostat that sets the target temperature to 99.9 °C.