I did a bit more searching and found this post:
I tried reformatting the SD cards using the SD Formatter utility from the SD Association as opposed to the one built into my OS and it worked!
Initializing SD card...Wiring is correct and a card is present.
Card type: SD2
Clusters: 61428
Blocks x Cluster: 64
Total Blocks: 3931392
Volume type is: FAT16
Volume size (Kb): 1965696
Volume size (Mb): 1919
Volume size (Gb): 1.87
Files found on the card (name, date and size in bytes):
SYSTEM~1/ 2024-02-13 09:04:52
INDEXE~1 2024-02-13 09:04:52 76