A degree in electronics (or something)?

This is mostly for @Grumpy_Mike because I know he used to be a university lecturer, but I would also welcome comments from anyone else.

I don't have a degree in anything. My knowledge of electricity comes first from my dad, who understood electrical circuits but not electronics, so house and industrial wiring, motors, car and commercial vehicle wiring (before they were electronic), that kind of thing. I even understood what Ward Leonard control for a DC motor was before I left school, other than my brother I don't know anyone else who knows that.

Practical Electronics (the magazine) then collage taught me electronics.

Working in an electronics repair shop taught me even more electronics.

This forum has only added to my knowledge.

So, the question:
If I wanted a degree in electronics how easy would that be? I've seen lots of questions on the forum from people doing degree courses and judging by what people are asked to do at university I ought to be given a degree just by turning up and asking for one.

What do you think?

Yes, but what subjects were they studying at university? If they are subjects that are on the more creative side, their questions are understandable because the courses won't go into much detail on digital or analog electronics or low-level programming.

I suspect that a degree in something like electronic engineering would be one of the most difficult courses you could choose, the maths involved would be pretty advanced, for example.

I remember one of the most difficult courses I took at Uni was on electromagnetics. The theory of designing wave guides for radio telescopes and radar antenna. The maths equations involved still make me shudder to think about them 40 years later!

Yes, I felt the same way. It took me two attempts to pass the exam in 'electromagnetic waves'. And today - a good 50 years later - I no longer have any chance of understanding the calculations. :rofl: :joy: :innocent:

Careful with that one. I had a hand in selecting tech new grads; it's one thing to graduate from a college, totally another to graduate from a competent college; universities have the same problem. Unless, of course, you're just looking for pretty paper to hang on a wall. I could print you one of those, but so could you. The raw material for that hangs in every bathroom.

You might get an idea by looking at some university web sites where courses where the curriculum and prerequisites for entry are specified. The theoretical part will be difficult if you don't have an academic background. But maybe this gives an idea: https://www.open.ac.uk/courses/computing-it/degrees/bsc-computing-and-electronic-engineering-r62

A lot of what it taught is of no real practical application and is only part of the weeding out process and once you reach a certain level of maturity, your portfolio of achievements is more useful on the job market than qualifications.

Here, it depends a bit on what the objectives are. Maybe just hiring a mortar board and silk gown and holding a rolled up sheet of paper for a few photographs could be enough. There are also academic institutions which issue qualifications indiscriminately.

knowledge in one subject proven by testing to a standard results in a certification. a degree demonstrates a spectrum of knowledge in many subjects. a degree in an American school requires a standard level of knowledge in history. English, psychology, a raft of disciplines. there are many things that any person with a masters degree knows, because a masters degree is also a standard. you have to jump through all the hoops.

No. Not even close. I STARTED college at about the same level of experience you have and that was no where near what was required for a (Electronics Engineering Technician) diploma, let alone a degree in Engineering or Computer Science.

My program required senior level credits in math, physics and chemistry, prior to acceptance. Then I had to do two more credits in math, including calculus.

Do you understand how your multimeter works? I had to take three semesters of instrumentation to complete my program.

I know I've forgotten half of the courses I took in a two year program.

Well, if it uses successive approximation in the A to D converter then pretty much.

Yes this was my go to source when I was at school, along with Practical Radio and Practical TV.

In those days (mid 60's) electronics was a term that wasn't understood by the general public. Certainly by my family when I got a job at a company where I was an apprentice technician. I did day release at the company where I studied for an HNC in electrical engineering. There were four modules, Physics, Maths , motors and electronics. I must admit that the motors stuff was my least favorite part of the course, and the Physics the most interesting.

Then I was told about University Courses in joint Physics and Electronics. So applied for some of those and got some interviews, one of them was Manchester. However, the offer I got came with the condition that I needed to get 70% in my Maths module.

On the day of the exams I knew I had passed the maths paper and I also knew I had not got 70%. So I was a bit down, so to cheer myself up I bought a copy of Practical Electronics. There was an advert for a "Physical Electronics degree" at Newcastle Polytechnic. So I applied before the results were out, not knowing about the clearing round at Universities.

I wrote a letter, you did in those days, and was asked to confirm I could attend an interview by a date, which turned out to be the day after tomorrow. I rang them up from work and confirmed this, only to find my boss behind me when I put down the phone. He said "have you got something to tell me?" I sheepish replied "can I have Thursday off work".

I went for an interview and was astonished by two men talking in the lift. I had never come across a Geordy accent before and I thought where the hell am I. In those days you never heard any accents on the media. Still I learnt the language and had a good four years there. It is where I had my only three lectures on computing but I was bitten by the bug and went on to use the computer system as a sort of side study. If you were lucky you could get two runs a day. The electronics part of the course in the final year was something I could have done from school, but the earlier parts were things like four parameter models of a transistor. A bit of maths of not a lot of practical stuff.

It was a "thick sandwich" course with one year being spent in industry / government research laboratories. I spent it at the Admiralty Underwater Weapons Establishment at Portland.

I was offered a PhD at Newcastle but turned it down for one I found in Salford by just ringing them. Newcastle was feeling a bit small of a city to me by then.

At Salford I got into micro processors with the only people who could understand them at the time were electronic engineers who could program. Right place at the right time, so when a job came up at Manchester Polytechnic needing these skills I applied and got the job from 40 applicants.

Yes but that is not how it works sadly. Have you considered the Open University? Have a look at the courses they offer.

In all seriousness Mike asking the question was a bit of Sunday afternoon fun and a way to see what other people's opinions were. The prompt being the questions we see here from people who are on courses of one kind or another, getting help from people possibly far less qualified than they will be if they successfully complete their course. I'm not really after getting a degree at the moment. OU or the University of Nottingham would be the obvious place for me to go, were that my desire.

Thanks for the comments.

I agree with the others posters.

What you’ve learned from experience and practical work is impressive and incredibly valuable, but a formal degree in electronics or CS, especially at the master’s or engineering level, involves much more than practical knowledge. It requires a solid foundation in mathematics, physics, and other related sciences, as well as theory and formal problem-solving skills.

You should consider why you want the degree—whether it’s for self-confidence, career advancement, higher salary, or another reason. Depending on your goals, other options might include gaining practical experience through internships, taking certifications, attending workshops or bootcamps, networking within the industry, or pursuing specialized training programs to enhance your skills and credibility.

If a formal degree fits your ambitions and opens doors you want, then it’s worth pursuing, but be prepared for the academic commitment involved.

If it is about increasing your income, get any degree from anywhere.
If it is about having a certificate, why measure yourself against anyone?
If it is about fulfilling your goals, you already have.

I had a friend with beautiful eyes and a masters in computer something-something, coding for a company who supplied software for countries to "pay" their employees. These countries needed "western" payroll software that used single-byte values translated into multi-byte values to represent their written characters. That person graduated with honors, and had a starting salary larger than my salary after two decades in the field... but needed help to get some scripts working.

So... I applied to a few tech universities. They rejected all nationally accepted "bypass" test credits, and dozens of nationally accepted scholastic credits (because History of Computers has changed so much?). They accepted four credits for physical education. I could meet with professors to bypass the "101" classes, but I would be required to accumulate as many credits as a 16 year old freshman to graduate with the same degree.

I did not need four or six years of sitting in a classroom to validate or increase my ability, or use my savings for a plaque to put beside my work-related plaques that had real meaning... or the real experience I gained while working.

University is not about learning. It is about paying a for-profit corporation for a rubber stamp so "HR" can use an app, rather than spotting the candidates who got through with a wink and a nod, say no more, say, no, more.

Vocation is roughneck, but makes the world operate in real time.

School teaching many decades ago was mainly watch my lips from teachers.
You never learnt how to learn.
I stated off with an EverReady battery, some fuse wire and a bulb. The bulb lit.
We used to have a radio club in the evening and apart from crystal sets, not much ever worked.
The days of Boys Own One valve shortwave set and white spot transistors, which never worked either.
Market stalls had a lot of useless ex army surplus radio stuff.
We did a bit of electrical stuff, no electronics then, mainly Ohms law, but again badly taught.
Only when I got through to post grad did I really get the hang of learning.
In work, I could see the value of electronics, still no accessible computers, and did a tech college basic electronics.
The only "coding" experience I had was Fortran..
By chance I stumbled on Arduino. It was a steep learning curve and my expertise is still very basic.
If I have one skill, it's dogged determination. At work, I took on the jobs no-one else wanted. Mainly problem solving.
Now I love the versatility of the micro and how it can help around the house.
These are probably the best times ever to do your own thing.
Access to the WWW is amazing and a far cry from the local library.
Logic and state machines still drive me mad and I confess to a lot of cut and paste.
My coding is more rural dead ends than fast lane motorways.
I really am glad I chances on Arduino.

I took a degree, chemistry, mainly through my own efforts.
The school I went to didn't encourage you much especially if you didn't like sports or getting your face pushed into the mud.
It was partly to test myself and partly to prove to the doubters that given the right surroundings, you could do it.

I note that a lot of successful, sometimes famous, people got their success with little formal education or certificates...

Hmmmm
Without naming names and starting on politicians, I can think of a few who fit that description.
Doing an honest job rarely makes you rich.

Perhaps I should have been clearer, I was thinking of people successful in business.

Not everywhere.

Decades ago, I was lucky to benefit from the French school system, which was essentially free all the way through to my engineering degree. I took a loan and worked on the side to cover accommodation, living expenses, but that (and the occasional skipped meal) only pushed me to study harder and complete my degree successfully.

Having that qualification — and probably the fact that I was somewhat good at it — opened doors early in my career and shaped my professional path.

Taking a degree much later in life is a different story. You’ll be entering a job market alongside younger graduates who typically have fewer responsibilities, different expectations, and are often seen as a blank slate to be shaped. Standing out won’t rely on the qualification alone, but on how you present your experience, transferable skills, and the value your background brings to the role. It’s absolutely possible, but it’s a different kind of challenge, and the reality is that employers looking for entry-level candidates often lean toward younger applicants.

A friend started an arts degree in his 30s, transferred to fashion and got well paid jobs designing clothes for supermarkets after he got his degree. When he was at university he told me stories of how many (by no means all) of the younger people on the course didn't really make much effort, turn up on time and the like. He, being there after a lot of consideration about what he wanted, made the required effort.

Because I did not go to a Grammar School, I went to a Secondary Modern, the lower tier school where you could leave at the age of 14. I did stay on to take exams and left when I was 16.

Because of my dyslexia ( which was not a thing in those days ) I was labeled as thick (stupid). So I did it mainly to show myself and others I was not. To be honest, I also also thought it would advance my love life, being a student (which it did but not as much as I had hoped :wink: )

In the end I discovered that by being dyslexic gave me a bit of an advantage. I was able to zoom in on the smallest detail and out to see the whole picture.

A thing I didn't know other people couldn't do.

:rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
Have you seen how poor academics get payed in the UK. It is a joke.

It wasn't until I was forced to leave because the department I was in was being split up, did I start having to pay the next rate of income tax. Yet all my graduate students started with a salary much in excess to mine.

Thanks but I haven't always been 73 although it does sound a lot older than it feels (apart from my stroke two years ago)