Grumpy_Mike, how can you say that? First of, it's proven technology. EEG has been used in the medical field for decades now, but without much pressure on further development because the huge, clunky and precise machines they use in hospitals fulfills their needs perfectly.
Now, what is an EEG? Something that picks up an electromagnetic field/signal, amplifies it and applies Fast Fourier Transform algorithms to the dirty, noise-like signal. Seems pretty straight forward, doesn't it..?
With hospitals using this tech for decades, and 3 different home-EEG products out, you can't really dispute the fact that it does work. So what are you whining about? What is it you think is rubbish? Do you not think we can consciously affect our brainwaves?
Check out http://www.nytimes.com/2007/08/26/business/yourmoney/26stream.html?_r=1
Here[ch8217]s how Omneuron uses fMRI to treat chronic pain: A patient slides into the coffin-like scanner and watches a computer-generated flame projected on the screen of virtual-reality goggles; the flame[ch8217]s intensity reflects the neural activity of regions of the brain involved in the perception of pain. Using a variety of mental techniques [ch8212] for instance, imagining that a painful area is being flooded with soothing chemicals [ch8212] most people can, with a little concentration, make the flame wax or wane. As the flame wanes, the patient feels better. Superficially similar to an older technology, electroencephalogram biofeedback, which measures electrical feedback across multiple areas of the brain, fMRI feedback measures the blood flow in precise areas of the brain.
Notice how medical experts are using fMRI (and EEG) to create a feedback loop that essensially lets the patient control activity in targeted areas of the brain? Ever read the countless studies about those pesky ADHD/ADD kids who get to play EEG-games where mental concentration and focus is rewarded/required? Check it out. The benefits they recieve are huge, even compared to putting them on drugs (not to mention more permanent, more healthy, etc.).
Lastly, I myself have the OCZ Neural Impulse Acutator. No, I am not one of those guys who sit through 30 minutes of randomness, and when the right thing happens go "YEAH, I did that, with my MIND!". I have used it (if sporadically) and can vouch for it working. When I look at the brainfingers screen I can, with a little effort, pull all the bars all the way down,and I have some control of one alpha and two beta channels.
My only real beef with the OCZ NIA is that once inside a game you don't see the analog feedback (brainfinger bars). You divide each bar into zones corresponding with an action (keypress, keydown, mouseclick, etc.) and without continous feedback it gets very difficult to know if you are moving the bar up or down.