Trouble with breadboards... any advice?

Hi all,

I am using breadboards to develop stuff, but lately have been experiencing nothing but trouble in low-voltage analog circuits. Like this simple common emitter amplifier:

Whatever I do, it never works properly. There's always some connection not working and to get it to work at all, I have to wiggle each and every connection until finally it works again - but usually it's more than one connection that is troublesome.

One problem is the resistors that have to thin leads; but even when I double those up in the same hole it's still the same, and it's also the connections that are not too thin.

Any suggestions? Better breadboards? Douse everything in contact cleaner? Other?

-M

Hello michaelwillems

I´m using this boards for prototying.

Hello

The "springs" may have become lose, especially if you had more than one thing in one hole.

2 Likes

I use strip-board. Like here:

https://create.arduino.cc/projecthub/michaelwillems/simple-bench-signal-generator-e560d0?ref=user&ref_id=1877097&offset=0

But this is even before prototyping: breadboards are the initial step, when I verify that it works; that my calculations are right, and so on. I can't solder yet because I have not yet verified the project, at this stage.

Some of the components have rather slim legs. Low cost bred boards.... No surprise if there are bad contacts.
Use protoboards and soldering as @ paulpaulson suggests.

Share tips you have come across - Using Arduino / General Electronics - Arduino Forum
This is the index, check out breadboard helpers.

2 Likes

problem of course is that I might well change out a resistor or capacitor ten times before settling on a final design... I'd hate to have to solder each and every time!

Cheap breadboards.. OK, so are there better breadboards available? Where do I buy them and how do I recognize a good one?

Mount some screw terminals on a set of pins.

2 Likes

I’ve been successfully using breadboards from 3M for decades but they are very expensive these days.

One way would be to use decade boxes whenever practical when “tweaking” a design.

2 Likes

Make up some breadboard helpers in advance.

Machine pin headers are easily to modify and easily plug into solderless breadboards.

Invest in at lease on resistor substitution board for tuning resistors.

Or make your own.

image

image

4 Likes

Most analog circuits can be simulated quite accurately with LTSpice, free to download.

1 Like

I've had good luck with breadboards made by Busboard Prototype Systems, which are available on Ebay, Amazon, Digikey. They were recommended in this video:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XKQJhe9n_ug

There is a BIG difference in breadboards, and bad ones can make your life miserable, as you have found.

1 Like

IMHO, I think it's a combination of the leads oxidizing and the board being of poor quality or near end of life.

I keep some 600 grit sandpaper here, when I find a flaky component I run the sandpaper over the lead real lightly.. This usually fixes the issue...

I agree, I'm not going to solder/unsolder until I get the circuit down..

Good luck

:smiley_cat:

1 Like

Best tip ever - thanks so much! I will be constructing those helpers.

That was a good tip: I am liking LTSpice (in spite of its awful Mac UI).

I use LTSpice all the time and find it extremely useful for getting a feel for how a circuit will perform.

It can be difficult to find accurate models for older op amps, as LT naturally supports their own line. PSPICE models don't necessarily work, due to some changes that LT has made in the code.

1 Like

This topic was automatically closed 180 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.